The Progressive Post

Manufacturing Dissent? Fake-news, Micro-targeting and Democracy

We need new rules and changes on different fronts,

FEPS President
18/02/2019

For this edition of the Progressive Post, we decided to focus on digital democracy. The European elections are nearing, and as a politician, I am looking forward to them. Elections are the hallmark of our democracy and a moment of optimism. But I am also vigilant, because it seems that our democracy is vulnerable to online manipulation, and that our capacity to take democratic decisions is under pressure from big technology firms.

In her book Surveillance Capitalism, Professor Shoshana Zuboff traces a rapidly spreading business model that revolves around the harvesting of personal data to predict, manipulate and control what people do. This mutation of capitalism, together with the sheer concentration of power in the digital economy, is undermining our individual autonomy, and hence the fundament of our democracy.

To counter this trend, we need new rules and changes on different fronts, but I think the way we do politics is a good place to start. We should not succumb to a race to the bottom, in which we gather ever more personal data, to better target and manipulate individual voters. I want to convince citizens with my ideas, and an initial one would be to enforce more transparency for online political adverts.

Of course, the digital age poses more challenges for our democracy. There are groups that deliberately set up disinformation campaigns. There is a real risk that public opinion will be manipulated ahead of the elections, and we should counter that decisively. It is also dispiriting to see the vitriol people feel licensed to spout online. This spoils our public debate and is a far cry from the democratic promise of the early internet.  

But I am wary of the political energy that is now being spent on combating ‘fake news’. The ‘internet’-based public debate needs to give voice to quality media but also to people who were not heard before, and we should cherish that. We should find ways to turn this cacophony of voices into a symphony, not turn off the sound altogether.

I am not naïve though. I see that the result is often ugly. When ugliness turns into criminality, we have the penal code, and it should be enforced. To do so, we need to work with platforms. But I think that mandating social media to take down content is a lazy man’s solution. Even with safeguards, this will lead to biased interventions and will cement big platforms’ influence over our communications. Most importantly, it will not solve problems; we just no longer see them.

Instead, I am convinced we should undertake the difficult, but crucial, work of engaging all citizens to create a better democracy. We need new models of communication that foster dialogue and that do not appeal to our basest instincts in order to maximise profits. In times of instantaneous communication, we should also reflect whether it is still appropriate that people’s political participation is limited to a single vote. In short, we need to rethink our democracy, to ensure it remains the best model to live together and prosper.

Find all related publications
Publications
05/03/2024

A European feminist foreign policy?

The need for a progressive and transformative approach
01/03/2024

The transformation of the mainstream right in Western Europe

Implications for social democracy
01/03/2024

Next Left Vol. 15

Progressive Ambition: How to shape Europe in the next decade
29/02/2024

The European political community

Informality as a key to success
Find all related news
News
18/03/2024

FEPS President on Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?’

NATO extension, Portuguese elections, far-right and gender equality were the topics of the debate
08/03/2024

Discover the updated EU Care Atlas!

07/03/2024

Call for videos – Your Call to Europe

This call closed on 24/03/2024
04/03/2024

FEPS at the PES Election Congress in Rome

Find all related in the media
In the media

Women leaders in CSOs—overworked, overwhelmed

by Social Europe 27/03/2024
This article published in the digital media Social Europe focuses on the findings of FEPS policy study 'Women CSO leaders for systemic change'

The EU pursues make-believe in Bosnia

by Financial Times 23/03/2024
Financial Times featured our policy brief 'Bosnia-Herzegovina', which analyses the journey of BiH's EU membership and the necessary reforms to make it happen

AI won’t replace quality journalism, but sector needs safeguarding, says socialist think tank head

by Euractiv 18/03/2024
Interview with FEPS President on the role of media in Europe’s future

FEPS President on Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?’

by Euronews 16/03/2024
FEPS President Maria João Rodrigues discusses NATO expansions and elections in Russia and Portugal on Euronews talk-show ‘Brussels, my love?‘